How can educators shift grading from a measure of performance to a tool for progress?
Grading Practices That Promote Equity and Growth
Grading should reflect what students know and are able to do, not where they started, what challenges they face, or how compliant they are. Yet in many schools, grading still includes behavior, punctuality, and effort, which can obscure learning and widen opportunity gaps.
To promote equity and support real academic growth, we must rethink traditional grading models and replace them with transparent, fair, and flexible practices that lift up all learners, especially those from historically underserved communities.
Why Traditional Grading Falls Short
Traditional grading systems often:
Penalize students for factors outside their control (e.g., late work due to responsibilities at home)
Emphasize averages instead of mastery
Reward compliance over critical thinking
Lack transparency - students and families don’t always know what a grade represents
Reinforce systemic inequities for multilingual learners, students with disabilities, and those from marginalized backgrounds
Equitable grading isn’t about lowering standards - it’s about making expectations fair and growth-focused for every student.
Principles of Equitable Grading
Effective, equitable grading practices should be:
Accurate - Reflect what students have learned
Bias-resistant - Minimize the impact of implicit bias
Growth-oriented - Support learning over time
Transparent - Clear to students and families
Flexible - Account for diverse learning needs and contexts
6 Practical Strategies for More Equitable Grading
1. Grade What Matters: Academic Mastery
Separate academic performance from behaviors like effort, attendance, or neatness.
Instead of: “Participation = 15% of grade”
Try: “Demonstrates understanding of key concepts through discussion and reflection tasks”
Why it works: It levels the playing field for students who may participate differently due to language, neurodiversity, or anxiety.
2. Allow for Retakes and Revisions
Mastery takes time. Provide students opportunities to improve their work based on feedback.
Classroom Example: A middle school ELA teacher allows students to revise analytical essays using teacher comments and self-reflection questions.
Why it works: Students learn that growth is the goal, not perfection on the first try.
3. Use Rubrics That Focus on Learning Goals
Design rubrics around learning standards, not vague criteria like “creativity” or “neatness.”
Tip: Share rubrics with students before the assignment and involve them in co-creating criteria.
4. Replace Zeros with Incompletes (and Follow Up)
A zero can sink a student’s grade and their motivation. Use “Incomplete” and allow students to revisit tasks.
Equity Example: A high school in New York moved to a no-zero grading policy and saw a 25% reduction in failure rates.
5. Avoid Averaging Over Time
A single bad day shouldn’t define a student’s performance. Use most recent or highest evidence of learning.
Example: If a student struggled with early quizzes but mastered the content later, the final grade should reflect that growth.
6. Make Feedback Part of the Grade
Shift focus from summative to formative assessment.
Strategy: Assign “feedback loops” where students reflect on teacher comments and make adjustments before final grading.
Turning stacks of student work into opportunities for growth and equity
Global Examples of Equitable Grading in Action
British Columbia, Canada
The province transitioned to proficiency scales (Emerging, Developing, Proficient, Extending) to replace traditional letter grades in K-9. This system promotes growth and clarity for both teachers and families.
Finland
Finland’s education system emphasizes formative assessment and student feedback over formal grades in the early years. Teachers track progress holistically and engage families through narrative reports.
New Zealand
Uses Learning Stories in primary education - narrative assessments that focus on student growth, learning behaviors, and strengths, often co-written with student and family input.
Administrator’s Role: Creating Conditions for Equitable Grading
Leaders must:
Provide PD on bias-aware grading and inclusive assessment
Promote standards-based grading systems that reflect mastery
Encourage teacher collaboration on rubric design and equitable feedback
Monitor grading data for disparities across race, language, ability, and gender
Give teachers time to reassess, reflect, and refine grading practices
Systemic equity requires systemic support.
Final Thoughts: Grade for What Matters
Grading is not just a record - it’s a message. It tells students what we value and how we define success.
When we align our grading with equity and growth:
Students feel seen, not sorted
Learning becomes the focus - not compliance
Grades support progress - not punishment
The goal of school is not just to measure learning - it’s to foster it.
Want more strategies?
Get Lesson Planning & Quick Assessment Toolkit — tools to design lessons, track progress, and assess learning with ease. Also featured in the Classroom Essentials Pack.
Lesson Planning & Quick Assessment Toolkit
Why Teachers Love It: Teachers love it because it makes planning and assessment more efficient, with easy-to-adapt tools that keep students engaged and progress measurable.
Start Strong with Classroom Essentials - Get everything you need to organize, plan, and manage your classroom in one convenient bundle. Perfect for new teachers or those looking to refresh their classroom systems. Why Teachers Love It: Saves hours of prep time and helps establish structure from day one.